Come and enjoy My Blue Heaven. It will become Your Blue Heaven! We are a smaller, but cozier establishment, and everyone who visits us is treated as family. You’ll sink into a feathery bed at night surrounded by décor from a simpler, less complicated time. In the morning, we’ll serve up something special, from hearty to healthy to gourmet. We have bicycles for you to tour around Chautauqua Lake or tour the many local wineries. Tell us what you’d like to do during your stay and we’ll work with you to make it happen!

We are Jean and Mike Lobaugh. We moved to Mayville in 2004, and bought this wonderful, fixer-upper Victorian Italianate. We underestimated the fixing up part! But we are extremely proud of what we have accomplished. For those who are interested we have countless destruction and reconstruction stories.

Mike is the ‘chef’. He is an engineer by trade, and he can engineer a meal you won’t soon forget. Jean is the decorator. She likes to move the furniture around (she won’t move your bed around mid-visit, promise!). Jean is a bean-counter by trade, but don’t hold that against her. Both Mike and Jean enjoy making folks comfortable, relaxed, and happy; It’s their mission to make your stay a memorable one.


  • Mike & Jean Lobaugh were crowned the Mayville's 31st Annual President’s Day Weekend Festival King & Queen.  Read More Here...

    Post Journal - 2/17/2018

  • My Blue Heaven featured on "Back Room Radio Hour".  Read Here...

    Post Journal - 1/4/2018

  • My Blue Heaven LLC was the recipient of the Business Improvement Award presented by the Mayville/Chautauqua Community Chamber of Commerce at their Annual Banquet and Meeting held at Andriaccio’s Restaurant, Mayville, on Nov. 16. Read More Here...

    Post Journal - 12/24/2017



General: Adults only; No smoking; no pets

Two-bedroom Apartment: Please be aware, our Weekly Apartment is only available through Airbnb now. Go to and look for “Apartment near Lake Chautauqua”.

Minimum Stays on weekends: All B&B rooms have a 2 Night (Fri & Sat) Minimum Policy on weekends from May 1st - October 31st. Any single night bookings during this time will be subject to cancellation.

Cancellations: At My Blue Heaven Bed and Breakfast, we care very much about our guests. If your travel plans change and you must cancel your reservation, normally we would require at least 5 (five) days notice. Due to the current pandemic, we will be accepting cancellations up to 24 hours before planned arrival.

Changes to Rates/Policies: Rates and Policies are subject to change and vary during high impact periods and special requests.

Check in/out: Check-in: 3:00 PM - 6:00 PM. If arriving outside of check-in times, please call to make arrangements. Check-out: 11:00 AM.